Matching numbers as Monza host Fiorentina
Monza and Fiorentina have more in common than first impressions suggest. The final fixture of Serie A Enilive Matchday 12 brings them together at the U-Power Stadium on Monday evening. Their squads were assembled with different ambitions and philosophies, and both sides feel their early-season performances have deserved a better return.
Ivan Jurić’s Monza have won admirers for their spirit and fearless football. With an average age of just 23.6, the lowest in the league, they have put their faith in an enthusiastic young squad, giving emerging talents and lesser-known players a chance to make their mark. However, they have struggled to turn that lively football into consistent results.
Fiorentina have a more experienced and technically gifted squad. A particularly difficult start has proved costly. The return of Paolo Vanoli has given the Viola a boost, but turning their potential into results remains a challenge.
An even head-to-head record
Past meetings and this season’s numbers point to an evenly matched game at the Brianteo.
In their six previous Serie A meetings, Monza and Fiorentina have won twice each, with two draws. Monza have a slight edge in Brianza, with two wins to Fiorentina’s one.
Their last meeting came in 2024/25, the season Monza were relegated to Serie B. It was the Biancorossi’s only home league win that season, a 2-1 victory over Fiorentina, then coached by former Monza boss Raffaele Palladino. Patrick Ciurria and Daniel Maldini scored for the hosts. That game, too, was played on a Monday evening.
The parallels are even more striking in this season’s numbers.
Same numbers, same problems
17 goals scored, 25 conceded and 18.4 expected goals each. After eleven matchdays, Monza and Fiorentina are level on three key measures. Both rank in the top half for goals scored and share the league’s second-worst defensive record. Only Sassuolo have conceded more (29). Those defensive frailties have undone much of their good work in attack and cost them points.
Fiorentina sit two points above Monza thanks to two extra draws, a slender margin that keeps them out of the relegation zone for now.
Monza’s accuracy and Fiorentina’s attacking intent
Monza lead Serie A for shooting accuracy, with 42% of their attempts on target. They also create high-quality chances, ranking sixth for big chances created (33) and fifth for expected goals per shot (0.17). Their finishing has been less effective, with a 27.9% conversion rate.
Fiorentina shoot more often, ranking fifth for total shots. They hit the target with 30% of their efforts and average just 0.10 xG per shot, one of the lowest figures in Serie A. They rank third for shots from distance and fourth for shots on the counter-attack. Vanoli’s side can move upfield quickly, break into the final third and find room to shoot. Too often they rush their shots or settle for efforts that pose little threat. When they hit the target, however, they convert 30.4% of those attempts, a higher rate than Monza’s.
Monza create better chances on average and have struggled to convert them. Fiorentina, meanwhile, take more shots, often from less favourable positions, and are more clinical when they hit the target. Different routes to the same goal tally, at least for now.
Defences in need of improvement
The parallels are even more striking in defence. Both sides have conceded 25 goals, well above their expected goals against (xGA) totals of 16 for Monza and 17.3 for Fiorentina. They have the two largest gaps between goals conceded and expected goals against in Serie A, having been punished more heavily than anyone else relative to the quality of the chances they have allowed.
The similarities extend to other measures. Both teams have faced 62 shots on target and made five errors that led directly to opposition goals. Their average possession figures are also close, with Fiorentina on 45% and Monza on 44%.
Who scores the goals
The way the goals are shared reveals a key difference in how the two attacks are built.
At Monza, Gustavo Varela is the standout. The Portuguese forward has scored nine of Monza’s 17 goals, more than half their total. He leads the league’s scoring charts and has become almost indispensable to Jurić’s attack. His teammates have contributed far fewer goals. Jay Robinson is the only other Monza player to have scored more than once, with two goals. Five others have one apiece and an opposition own goal completes the tally.
Fiorentina, by contrast, spread the goals more evenly. Mateo Pellegrino and Franco Mastantuono lead the club’s scoring charts with four goals each, followed by Nije (3) and Jiménez (2). The Viola have four players with two or more goals, twice as many as Monza. Vanoli’s side also have more individual scorers overall, with eight to Monza’s seven.
A change of tune
Monday’s fixture has the makings of an entertaining, high-scoring contest. Two bold sides who create chances as readily as they concede them meet with valuable points at stake.
Monza and Fiorentina need to change the script. Both have shown energy and enterprise and now need sharper finishing and greater defensive solidity to turn good football into vital points. Otherwise, they risk more of the same.